The Importance of Swatching

“Why bother?” This is a common response from many of my fellow fiber enthusiasts when the topic of swatching arises. They often question, “What’s the point if I’m not a designer?” Some friends proudly belong to the "no swatching" camp, which I find quite bamboozling. My viewpoint stems not only from my role as a designer who relies on swatches for accurate size grading but also from the insights gathered through years of knitting experience.

Understanding Reluctance Towards Swatching

Before we dive into the significance of crafting that simple 4”x4” square of fabric, it’s essential to grasp why some people overlook swatching’s value. I surveyed my fiber friends to understand their hesitations, and their responses were surprisingly consistent. Many expressed a desire to avoid wasting time since they already knew their gauge for the upcoming pattern. Others voiced concerns about wasting yarn, while some simply refused to swatch altogether, showing a stubbornness that didn’t seem logical. I cherish my friends, yet it can be frustrating when they dismiss the practice of swatching.

Why Swatching is Essential

So, why is swatching so crucial, and why do I advocate for it before every project? Yes, you heard me correctly—EVERY project! While not every endeavor requires a complete 4”x4” swatch, it’s vital to verify that your gauge hasn’t changed before starting something new.

Factors that can influence your gauge, even with the same needle size and yarn, include changing needle types—bamboo, hardwood, and metal can all affect your tension enough to alter your project’s intended sizing.

Not all yarns within the same weight category behave alike. For example, a DK weight with cashmere will drape beautifully, while a non-superwash DK will offer more structure. This difference is especially apparent after steam or wet blocking, as various fiber contents will respond uniquely once blocked.

Knitting with the same yarn on different types of needles can yield vastly different gauge results, and using yarns with varying fiber contents can also impact gauge outcomes, debunking the notion that “I know my gauge for that needle size and yarn weight.”

But what about those projects where you’ve previously used the exact yarn and needle? Personally, my gauge has fluctuated significantly since I began knitting, and it can vary depending on how frequently I knit or if I’ve taken a short break. My emotional state also plays a significant role in my tension. While working on an intricate dress design, I could sense the difference in my tension during the skirt section, reflecting my emotional struggles at that time!

Additional Benefits of Swatching

Now that you understand the necessity of swatching for every project, let’s look at the additional advantages and how to shift your mindset about this charming little square.

Colorway Visualization: Swatching enables you to see how a colorway will appear in your project. This is especially important for hand-dyed yarns or projects using multiple strands. As a yarn dyer, I appreciate swatching for its ability to showcase how a colorway will look, ensuring even color distribution and preventing unsightly pooling, which is generally not preferred. Imagine discovering after HOURS of knitting that the skein you loved doesn’t work for your project—no, thank you!

Drape Assessment: More crucial than colorway (there’s always overdyeing) is the drape. As mentioned earlier, different fiber contents behave differently in terms of gauge and drape. If you’re crafting a lovely, flowy sweater, you definitely don’t want to use a yarn with minimal drape. Swatching and blocking significantly impact the wearability of your garment. Ultimately, the goal is to knit with intention, creating a piece you’ll cherish for years. While many of us enjoy the process of knitting, being intentional with our projects is beneficial.

Overcoming the Casting-On Urge: I admit I’ve felt the itch to cast on after working on one project for too long more times than I would like to admit. There should be a study on the endorphins knitters get from starting new projects! I am sure every reader knows exactly what I mean. As a designer, I’ve often jumped right into casting on after an idea strikes, only to abandon the project days later due to incorrect gauge, poor drape, or realizing that the fun hand-dyed yarn I was eager to use was all wrong for my initial vision.

Recently, I cleared out my personal yarn-bookcase to prepare for the amazing sample knits I’m creating for my business, and I was embarrassed by the number of abandoned projects I had stored away—none of which had swatches.

Through this more structured and organized approach to knitting for my business’s samples (I cannot waste precious knitting time), I’ve learned that taking the time to swatch creates intention for your project from the very start. It allows me to get excited about a project while only committing about an hour to the swatch. Sometimes, just knitting the swatch satisfies that casting-on itch. If the swatch turns out well, I feel more confident about starting the actual project. If it doesn’t? Well, I’ve only wasted an hour.

Addressing Yarn Waste Concerns

Now, regarding the concern about wasting yarn—I don’t see it that way. This perspective isn't solely because I have a business, as swatches of my hand-dyed yarn will always serve a purpose. Even if I didn’t have my business, I adore those little swatches. If I were knitting them for personal projects, keeping them in a binder would be a sweet keepsake. Imagine being in your 80s and flipping through a binder filled with all the swatches you created—a delightful stroll down memory lane! Not into that idea? Consider making a scrap sweater or cardigan from your swatches, or even a baby blanket or scarf. The possibilities are endless! And if you don’t like the swatch, don’t cut it from the cake or ball of yarn—wind it back up for future projects.

I hope that after reading this, you recognize the importance of swatching and remember that knitting is about taking it slow while creating something with love and intention. Think of your swatches as tiny pieces of your heart, hands, and creative thoughts.

Happy Knitting!

Colorway shown in photos is 'Hot Summer Nights' in our super soft cashmere blend 'Sirena Sock'. This is a limited edition colorway and will be available for pre-order after Flock Fiber Festival August 3rd 2026!

Sign up to our VIP newsletter to get first access.